Table 1 Articles not reporting work-related outcomes in osteoarthritis (excluded after review of full text PDF publications)
Reference | Reason for exclusion |
|---|---|
Hand osteoarthritis | |
Barthel 2010 [32] | Impact of hand OA mentioned in ‘Discussion’ section, but no work-related outcome was reported |
Nieman 2013 [33] | Work disability and inability to work due to knee OA were mentioned in ‘Background’ section, but no work-related outcome was reported |
Pope 2004 [34] | Though job status (% working full time, part-time, retired, homemaker) was reported, no work-related outcomes were reported |
Richmond 2013 [35] | Number of patients in paid employment reported as part of subjects’ baseline characteristics, but no work-related outcome was reported |
Taibi 2009 [36] | Number of patients working mentioned as a part of patients’ baseline characteristics but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Hip osteoarthritis | |
Cheras 2010 [37] | ‘Work disability’ mentioned in ‘Introduction’ section but no work-related outcome measure was reported for study subjects |
Ernst 2003 [38] | Systematic review |
Florete 2008 [39] | ‘Leading cause of disability; ‘cost’ estimated as ‘lost productive work time’; mentioned as effects of OA in ‘Introduction’ section, but no work-related outcome measure was reported for study subjects |
Gana 2006 [40] | ‘Leading cause of disability; ‘cost’ estimated as ‘lost productive work time’; mentioned as effects of OA in ‘Introduction’ section, but no work-related outcome measure was reported for study subjects |
Jabbari 2011 [41] | Review article |
Lambert 2007 [42] | No work-related outcome measure was reported |
Maheu 1998 [43] | ‘Number or percent of patients’ included in the study and still working was mentioned as a baseline characteristic but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Moskowitz 2003 [44] | Study was a pooled analysis and not a randomized controlled trial |
Plosker 2011 [45] | Review article |
Pope 2004 [34] | Though job status (% working full time, part-time, retired, homemaker) was mentioned as subjects’ baseline characteristics, no work-related outcome was reported separately |
Rozendaal 2005 [46] | Randomized controlled trial study protocol design |
Turan 2014 [47] | Loss of labor force mentioned in ‘Introduction’ section only, but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Willich 2010 [48] | Employment status (full/part-time) mentioned as part of patients’ baseline characteristic, but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Knee osteoarthritis | |
Alfredo 2011 [49] | Absenteeism due to OA was mentioned in ‘Introduction’ section, but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Auw Yang 2008 [50] | Cost due to loss of productivity at work mentioned in ‘Discussion’ section, but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Babul 2004 [51] | Lost work days due to OA mentioned in ‘Introduction’ section, but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Brown 2013 [52] | Review article |
Burch 2007 [53] | Cost due to lost productive work time mentioned in ‘Introduction’ section, but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Cheras 2010 [37] | Costs associated with OA and work disability mentioned in ‘Introduction’ section, but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Cibere 2005 [54] | Work disability and costs associated with knee OA mentioned in ‘Introduction’ section, but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Florete 2008 [39] | ‘Leading cause of disability’; ‘cost’ estimated as ‘lost productive work time’; mentioned as effects of OA in ‘Introduction’ section, but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Frakes 2011 [55] | Normal work mentioned as a part of secondary assessment questionnaire due to pain, but no work-related outcome measure was reported separately |
Gana 2006 [40] | ‘Leading cause of disability’; ‘cost’ estimated as ‘lost productive work time’; mentioned as effects of OA in ‘Introduction’ section, but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Hsieh 2012 [56] | Work status mentioned as a baseline characteristic but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Hsieh 2012 [57] | Work status mentioned as a baseline characteristic but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Hsieh 2012 [58] | Work status mentioned as a baseline characteristic but no work-related outcome measure was reported |
Ilan 2004 [59] | Delay in return to work mentioned in ‘Introduction’ section and not reported elsewhere |
Jia 2016 [60] | ‘Patients maintaining their work activities’ was mentioned in the ‘Discussion’ session, but no outcome measure was reported |
Kannus 1992 [61] | Ability to work mentioned as part of assessment of pain due to OA, but no outcome measure was reported |
Maheu 1998 [43] | ‘Number or percent of patients’ included in the study and still working was mentioned, but no outcome measure was reported |
Magrans-Courtney 2011 [62] | Ability to work mentioned as part of assessment of pain due to OA, but no outcome measure was reported |
Mata 2015 [63] | ‘Reduced participation in work’ mentioned in ‘Introduction’ section, but no outcome measure was reported |
Möller 2010 [64] | Work mentioned as part of patients’ assessment tool, but no outcome measure was reported |
Mazzuca 2004 [65] | Employment status mentioned as a part of patients’ baseline characteristics, but no outcome measure was reported |
Pavelka 1995 [66] | Employment status mentioned as a part of patients’ baseline characteristics, but no outcome measure was reported |
Pincus 2001 [67] | Employment status mentioned as a part of patients’ baseline characteristics, but no outcome measure was reported |
Pope 2004 [34] | Though job status (% of patients working full time, part-time, retired, homemaker) was mentioned as subjects’ baseline characteristics, no work-related outcome was reported |
Sanghi 2013 [68] | Disability leading to work loss mentioned in ‘Introduction’ section, but no outcome measure was reported |
Schauss 2012 [69] | Inability to work mentioned in the ‘Methods’ section, but no outcome measure was reported |
Segal 2001 [70] | ‘Hampers work’ mentioned in ‘Introduction’ section, but no outcome measure was reported |
Sihvonen 2013 [71] | Work mentioned as part of patients’ baseline characteristics, but no outcome measure was reported |
Singer 2011 [72] | ‘Work activities’ mentioned as part of questionnaire to assess quality of life, but no outcome measure was reported |
Taverner 2010 [73] | ‘Usual work’ mentioned as part of outcome measurement tool, but no outcome measure was reported separately |
van der Weegen 2015 [74] | Effect of OA pain on work was mentioned in ‘Introduction’ section; work activities mentioned as part of assessment tool, but no outcome measure was reported separately |
Zhao 1999 [75] | Work mentioned as part of quality of life assessment tool, but no outcome measure was reported separately |