Skip to main content

Table 5 Summary of the associations between activity groups* and health factors

From: Digitally connected work and its consequences for strain – a systematic review

First author, publication year

Activity group cluster (iv)

Health outcome cluster (dv)

Number of reported associations in total**

Number of reported direct associations with statistical analysis

Number of reported associations without statistical analysis

Direction of effects ***

Number of reported effects with work/health variables as moderator /mediator/ control

[4, 29];

[109]; [114]

activity group 1 (extent of technology use)

Motivation and satisfaction (12)

11

1

inconclusive

 0

  

Reduced well-being / affective symptoms (9)

2

7

not significant

 0

  

Physiological parameters and somatic complaints (43)

34

9

significant positive

 0

[17]

activity group 2 (before and after automation/computerization)

Motivation and satisfaction (0)

0

0

 

 0

  

Reduced well-being / affective symptoms (1)

1

0

not significant

 0

  

Physiological parameters and somatic complaints (6)

6

0

significant positive

 0

[5865, 99 111]

activity group 3 (level and extent of mental tasks)

Motivation and satisfaction (7)

3

4

inconclusive

 0

  

Reduced well-being / affective symptoms (11)

8

3

significant positive

 0

  

Physiological parameters and somatic complaints (8)

4

4

significant positive

 0

  1. * this table refers to group comparisons and the association was reported with the group with the highest extent of technology use, the group after automation, or the group with the highest level of mental tasks
  2. ** number of papers represented by the counts: see Fig. 3
  3. *** summary assessment independent of underlying construct; significant negative/significant positive = if 75% of reported associations are significant negative/significant positive and the rest is not significant; all other combinations: inconclusive; not significant = no significant association at all